MG Comet EV vs Tata Punch
Should you buy MG Comet EV or Tata Punch? Find out which car is best for you - compare the two models on the basis of their Price, Size, Space, Boot Space, Service cost, Mileage, Features, Colours and other specs. MG Comet EV price starts at Rs 7 Lakh ex-showroom for Executive (Electric) and Tata Punch price starts Rs 6 Lakh ex-showroom for Pure (Petrol).
Comet EV Vs Punch
| Key Highlights | MG Comet EV | Tata Punch |
|---|---|---|
| On Road Price | Rs.10,20,953* | Rs.11,96,298* |
| Range (km) | 230 | - |
| Fuel Type | Electric | Petrol |
| Battery Capacity (kWh) | 17.3 | - |
| Charging Time | 7.5KW 3.5H(0-100%) | - |
MG Comet EV vs Tata Punch comparison
- MG Comet EV
- Executive (Electric) 7 Lakh*
- Excite (Electric) 8.08 Lakh*
- Top SellingExcite FC (Electric) 8.56 Lakh*
- Exclusive (Electric) 9.12 Lakh*
- Exclusive FC (Electric) 9.49 Lakh*
- 100 Year Limited Edition (Electric) 9.65 Lakh*
- Blackstorm Edition (Electric) 9.81 Lakh*
Rs9.81 Lakh *VS - Tata Punch
- Pure (Petrol) 6 Lakh*
- Pure Opt (Petrol) 6.82 Lakh*
- Adventure (Petrol) 7.17 Lakh*
- Adventure Plus (Petrol) 7.52 Lakh*
- Top SellingAdventure Rhythm (Petrol) 7.52 Lakh*
- Adventure S (Petrol) 7.72 Lakh*
- Adventure AMT (Petrol) 7.77 Lakh*
- Adventure Plus AMT (Petrol) 8.12 Lakh*
- Adventure Rhythm AMT (Petrol) 8.12 Lakh*
- Adventure Plus S (Petrol) 8.22 Lakh*
- Adventure S AMT (Petrol) 8.32 Lakh*
- Accomplished Plus (Petrol) 8.42 Lakh*
- Accomplished Plus Camo (Petrol) 8.57 Lakh*
- Adventure Plus S AMT (Petrol) 8.82 Lakh*
- Accomplished Plus S (Petrol) 8.90 Lakh*
- Accomplished Plus S Camo (Petrol) 9.07 Lakh*
- Accomplished Plus AMT (Petrol) 9.02 Lakh*
- Creative Plus (Petrol) 9.12 Lakh*
- Creative Plus Camo (Petrol) 9.27 Lakh*
- Accomplished Plus Camo AMT (Petrol) 9.17 Lakh*
- Accomplished Plus S AMT (Petrol) 9.50 Lakh*
- Accomplished Plus S Camo AMT (Petrol) 9.67 Lakh*
- Creative Plus S (Petrol) 9.57 Lakh*
- Creative Plus AMT (Petrol) 9.72 Lakh*
- Creative Plus S Camo (Petrol) 9.72 Lakh*
- Creative Plus Camo AMT (Petrol) 9.87 Lakh*
- Creative Plus S AMT (Petrol) 10.17 Lakh*
- Creative Plus S Camo AMT (Petrol) 10.32 Lakh*
- Top SellingPure CNG (CNG) 7.30 Lakh*
- Adventure CNG (CNG) 8.12 Lakh*
- Adventure Plus CNG (CNG) 8.47 Lakh*
- Adventure Rhythm CNG (CNG) 8.47 Lakh*
- Adventure S CNG (CNG) 8.67 Lakh*
- Adventure Plus S CNG (CNG) 9.17 Lakh*
- Accomplished Plus CNG (CNG) 9.52 Lakh*
- Accomplished Plus Camo CNG (CNG) 9.67 Lakh*
- Accomplished Plus S CNG (CNG) 10 Lakh*
- Accomplished Plus S Camo CNG (CNG) 10.17 Lakh*
Rs10.32 Lakh *VS - Renault Kiger
- RXE (Petrol) 6.10 Lakh*
- RXL (Petrol) 6.85 Lakh*
- RXL AMT (Petrol) 7.35 Lakh*
- RXT Opt (Petrol) 8 Lakh*
- RXT Opt DT (Petrol) 8.23 Lakh*
- RXT AMT Opt (Petrol) 8.50 Lakh*
- RXT AMT Opt DT (Petrol) 8.73 Lakh*
- Top SellingRXZ (Petrol) 8.80 Lakh*
- RXZ DT (Petrol) 9.03 Lakh*
- RXZ Turbo (Petrol) 10 Lakh*
- RXT Opt Turbo CVT DT (Petrol) 10.23 Lakh*
- RXZ Turbo DT (Petrol) 10.23 Lakh*
- RXT Opt Turbo CVT (Petrol) 10.30 Lakh*
- RXZ Turbo CVT (Petrol) 11 Lakh*
- RXZ Turbo CVT DT (Petrol) 11.23 Lakh*
Rs6.10 Lakh *
Basic Information
| On-Road Price in New Delhi | Rs.10,20,953* | Rs.11,96,298* | Rs.6,81,971* |
| Finance Available (EMI) | Rs.19,435/month Get EMI Offers | Rs.22,762/month Get EMI Offers | Rs.12,985/month Get EMI Offers |
| Insurance | Rs.40,153 | Rs.43,189 | Rs.29,277 |
| User Rating | Based on 216 Reviews | Based on 1325 Reviews | Based on 498 Reviews |
| Service Cost (Avg. of 5 years) | - | Rs.4,712.3 | - |
| Brochure | Brochure not available | Brochure not available | |
| Running Cost Running cost per km measures the expense of driving your EV per kilometer. Running Cost/Km = (Battery Capacity of EV * Per Unit Electricity Cost ) / Range on full charge.✕ | ₹ 0.75/km | - | - |
Engine & Transmission
| Engine Type Engine type in car refers to the type of engine that powers the vehicle. There are many different types of car engines, but the most common are petrol (gasoline) and diesel engines✕ | Not applicable | 1.2 l Revotron | 1.0L Energy |
| Displacement (cc) The displacement of an engine is the total volume of all of the cylinders in the engine. Measured in cubic centimetres (cc)✕ | Not applicable | 1199 | 999 |
| No. of Cylinders ICE engines have one or more cylinders. More cylinders typically mean more smoothness and more power, but it also means more moving parts and less fuel efficiency.✕ | Not applicable | 33 Cylinder Cars | 33 Cylinder Cars |
| Fast Charging Fast charging typically refers to direct current (DC) charging from an EV charge station, and is generally quicker than AC charging. Not all fast chargers are equal, though, and this depends on their rated output.✕ | Yes | Not applicable | Not applicable |
View More View Less | |||
Fuel & Performance
| Fuel Type | Electric | Petrol | Petrol |
| Mileage City (kmpl) | - | - | 15 |
| Mileage Highway (kmpl) | - | - | 17 |
| Mileage ARAI (kmpl) | - | 18.8 | 19.17 |
View More View Less | |||
Suspension, Steering & Brakes
| Front Suspension The system of springs, shock absorbers, and linkages that connects the front wheels to the car body. Reduces jerks over bad surfaces and affects handling.✕ | MacPherson Strut suspension | MacPherson Strut suspension | MacPherson Strut suspension |
| Rear Suspension The system of springs, shock absorbers, and linkages that connects the rear wheels to the car body. It impacts ride quality and stability.✕ | Multi-link suspension | Rear twist beam | Rear twist beam |
| Steering Type The mechanism by which the car's steering operates, such as manual, power-assisted, or electric. It affecting driving ease.✕ | Electric | Electric | Electric |
| Steering Column The shaft that connects the steering wheel to the rest of the steering system to help maneouvre the car.✕ | Tilt | Tilt | No |
View More View Less | |||
Dimensions & Capacity
| Length (mm) The distance from a car's front tip to the farthest point in the back.✕ | 2974 | 3827 | 3991 |
| Width (mm) The width of a car is the horizontal distance between the two outermost points of the car, typically measured at the widest point of the car, such as the wheel wells or the rearview mirrors✕ | 1505 | 1742 | 1750 |
| Height (mm) The height of a car is the vertical distance between the ground and the highest point of the car. It can decide how much space a car has along with it's body type and is also critical in determining it's ability to fit in smaller garages or parking spaces✕ | 1640 | 1615 | 1605 |
| Ground Clearance Unladen (mm) The unladen ground clearance is the vertical distance between the ground and the lowest point of the car when the car is empty. More ground clearnace means when fully loaded your car won't scrape on tall speedbreakers, or broken roads.✕ | - | 187 | 205 |
View More View Less | |||
Comfort & Convenience
| Power Steering Mechanism that reduces the effort needed to operate the steering wheel. Offered in various types, including hydraulic and electric.✕ | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Automatic Climate Control Automatically adjusts the car’s cabin temperature. Removes the need to manually adjust car AC temperature every now and then & offers a set it and forget it convenience.✕ | - | Yes | No |
| Accessory Power Outlet 12V power socket to power your appliances, like phones or tyre inflators.✕ | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Vanity Mirror A mirror, usually located behind the passenger sun shade, used to check one's appearance. More expensive cars will have these on the driver's side and some cars even have this feature for rear seat passengers too.✕ | Yes | - | No |
View More View Less | |||
Interior
| Tachometer A tachometer shows how fast the engine is running, measured in revolutions per minute (RPM). In a manual car, it helps the driver know when to shift gears.✕ | - | Yes | Yes |
| Leather Wrapped Steering Wheel | - | Yes | - |
| Leather Wrap Gear Shift Selector | - | Yes | - |
View More View Less | |||
Exterior
| Available Colours | Green With Black Roof Candy White With Starry Black Apple Green With Starry Black Starry Black Aurora Silver +1 MoreComet EV Colours | Calypso Red With White Roof Tropical Mist Meteor Bronze Orcus White Dual Tone Daytona Grey Dual Tone +5 MorePunch Colours | Ice Cool White Stealth Black Moonlight Silver Radiant Red Caspian Blue Kiger Colours |
| Body Type | HatchbackAll Hatchback Cars | SUVAll SUV Cars | SUVAll SUV Cars |
| Adjustable Headlamps | - | Yes | - |
View More View Less | |||
Safety
| Anti-lock Braking System (ABS) A safety system that prevents a car's wheels from locking up during hard braking to maintain steering control.✕ | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Central Locking A system that locks or unlocks all of the car's doors simultaneously with the press of a button. A must-have feature in modern cars.✕ | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Child Safety Locks Safety locks located on the car's rear doors that, when engaged, allows the doors to be opened only from the outside. The idea is to stop the door from opening unintentionally.✕ | - | - | Yes |
| Anti Theft Alarm An alarm system that sounds when anyone tries to access the car forcibly or break into it.✕ | Yes | - | - |
View More View Less | |||
Entertainment & Communication
| Radio AM/FM radio tuner for listening to broadcasts and music. Mainly used for listening to music and news when inside the car.✕ | Yes | Yes | No |
| Integrated 2DIN Audio | - | - | No |
| Wireless Phone Charging Charges phones wirelessly via a charging pad. Useful feature for users with a smartphone that supports wireless charging.✕ | - | Yes | No |
| Bluetooth Connectivity Allows wireless connection of devices to the car’s stereo for calls or music.✕ | Yes | Yes | No |
View More View Less | |||
Pros & Cons
- Pros
- Cons
MG Comet EV
- Small proportions, makes the car ideal for city use.
- Premium look and feel of the interiors
- Up to 250km of claimed range
- Highlight features include two 10.25 inch screens, Wireless Android Auto and Apple CarPlay, connected car features, and keyless entry.
- Feels peppy and effortless to drive in the city
- Space for 4 adults
Tata Punch
- Striking looks
- High quality cabin
- Great interior space and comfort
- Ride comfort over bad roads
- Now gets a larger 10.25-inch touchscreen
- 5-star Global NCAP safety rating
MG Comet EV
- No boot space without folding the rear seats
- Ride comfort over bad roads
- Not at all a highway car, hence not an allrounder
Tata Punch
- Engine feels short on power for highway drives
- No cupholders for rear seat passengers
Research more on Comet EV and Punch
- Expert Reviews
- Recent News
- Must Read Articles
MG Comet EV 4000 km Review: It’s Hard To Say Goodbye
The Comet EV has been with us for 10 months, and it has proved itself to be a near-perfect city comm...
By Ansh Nov 20, 2024
MG Comet EV Long Term Report: 2,500 Km Driven
The Comet EV has switched hands, been driven for another 1000 km, and its purpose has become a lot c...
By Ansh Jun 28, 2024
MG Comet: Long Term Report (1,500km Update)
The MG Comet is a great urban mobility solution, but not one without a few drawbacks...
By Ujjawall May 15, 2024
Tata Altroz vs Punch vs Nexon: Space And Practicality Compared
Three Tata models, with completely different body styles, but a lot of commonality if you take a clo...
By CarDekho Mar 05, 2022
Tata Punch vs Nissan Magnite vs Renault Kiger: Space And Practicality Compared
The Punch is promising to offer the versatility and practicality of a sub-4 metre SUV in a shorter f...
By Nabeel Dec 29, 2021
Tata Punch: First Drive Review
With the Punch, Tata is trying to deliver a knockout blow to its competition. Have they succeeded?...
By CarDekho Oct 09, 2021
MG Comet EV Blackstorm Edition Launched
The all-black Blackstorm edition of the Comet EV is based on its top-spec Exclusive variant...
By Shreyash Feb 26, 2025
MG Comet EV Blackstorm Edition Teased For The First Time, Exterior Design Showcased With Black Colour And Red Accents
Except for changes including an all-black exterior and interior theme, the mechanicals and feature s...
By Dipan Feb 25, 2025
MG Comet EV Blackstorm Edition In The Works, Here’s What To Expect
The MG Comet EV is expected to be the fourth model in MG India’s lineup to receive this all-black ed...
By Shreyash Feb 04, 2025
Top 10 Most Affordable CNG Cars In India
Maruti dominates the list with over half of the most affordable CNG cars belonging to the Indian car...
By Kartik Feb 26, 2025
Tata Punch Crosses 5 Lakh Sales Units Milestone Since Launch
The Tata Punch has consistently been one of the most popular models because of its well rounded pack...
By Yashika Jan 22, 2025
These Were The Top 15 Best Selling Cars In December 2024
December sales saw Maurti in the first four spots, followed by Tata and Hyundai...
By Kartik Jan 09, 2025
Citroen C3 vs Tata Punch: Real-world Petrol-manual Fuel Efficiency Compared
We find out which of these unique rivals to conventional hatchbacks with similar performance is better for your fuel budget
By Sonny Dec 19, 2022
Videos of MG Comet EV and Tata Punch
- Full Videos
- Shorts
- 5:12MG Comet EV Vs Tata Tiago EV Vs Citroen eC3 | Price, Range, Features & More |Which Budget EV To Buy?1 year ago | 45.1K Views
- 14:47Tata Punch vs Nissan Magnite vs Renault Kiger | पंच या sub-4 SUV? | Space And Practicality Compared3 years ago | 621.6K Views
- 8:22MG Comet EV Variants Explained: Pace, Play, And Plush | Price From Rs 7.98 Lakh | Cardekho.com1 year ago | 5.6K Views
- 4:54MG Comet: Pros, Cons Features & Should You Buy It?1 year ago | 27.8K Views
- 15:57Living With The MG Comet EV | 3000km Long Term Review6 months ago | 36.2K Views
- 23:34MG Comet Detailed Review: Real World Range, Features And Comfort Review1 year ago | 73.8K Views
- 12:43Tata Punch - SUV Enough? Can it knock out competition? | First Drive Review | Powerdrift3 years ago | 131.5K Views
- 5:07Tata Punch Launch Date, Expected Price, Features and More! | सबके छक्के छुड़ा देगी?1 year ago | 488.8K Views
- 3:23Tata Punch Confirmed Details Out | What’s Hot, What’s Not? | ZigFF3 years ago | 44.6K Views
- 14:07MG Comet Drive To Death | Smallest EV Car Tested | ZigWheels.com1 year ago | 9.5K Views
- 2:31Tata Punch Crash Test Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ | यहाँ भी SURPRISE है! | #in2mins1 year ago | 199.7K Views
- Miscellaneous3 months ago |
- MG Comet- Boot Space6 months ago | 1 View
Comet EV comparison with similar cars
Punch comparison with similar cars
Compare cars by Bodytype
- Hatchback
- SUV
Find the right car
- By Budget
- By Vehicle Type
- By Fuel
- By Seating Capacity
- By Popular Brand
- By Transmission
Questions & answers
Q ) Which car is cheaper between MG Comet EV and Tata Punch?
A ) MG Comet EV price starts at ₹ 7 Lakh & Tata Punch price starts at ₹ 6 Lakh in New Delhi. Tata Punch is cheaper between these two cars.
*Ex-showroom price in New Delhi