Maruti Celerio VXi CNG vs Tata Tiago XM CNG: Specifications Compared

Modified On Jun 20, 2024 01:24 PM By Dipan for Maruti Celerio

23.8K Views
Write a comment

Two CNG-powered hatchbacks that are extremely fuel efficient for their price point. Which will you choose?

The Maruti Celerio and Tata Tiago have been on the market for a long time. These models are frequently seen competing in monthly hatchback sales charts. These hatchbacks get a CNG option, with comparable pricing and feature sets. We compare the specifications of both cars to see which one is best for you.

Price

Variant	Maruti Celerio VXi CNG	Tata Tiago XE CNG	Tata Tiago XM CNG
Price	Rs 6.74 lakh	Rs 6.60 lakh	Rs 6.95 lakh

Prices are ex-showroom, pan-India

While the direct rival for the one-above-base Celerio Vxi CNG is the Tiago XM CNG, the base-spec Tiago XE CNG is priced close enough to be included in this comparison as the cheapest option here. The entry-level XE variant of the Tata Tiago is Rs 14,000 less than the Maruti Celerio VXi CNG variant, which is the sole CNG variant in the Celerio range. There is another XM CNG variant of the Tiago which costs Rs 21,000 more than the Celerio CNG.

Celerio VXi CNG

Dimensions

Dimensions	Maruti Celerio CNG	Tata Tiago CNG
Length	3695 mm	3765 mm
Width	1655 mm	1677 mm
Height	1555 mm	1535 mm
Wheelbase	2435 mm	2400 mm

Tata Tiago CNG XM trim

Powertrain

Powertrain	Maruti Celerio CNG	Tata Tiago CNG
Engine	1-litre three-cylinder engine	1.2-litre three-cylinder engine
Power	57 PS	73 PS
Torque	82 Nm	95 Nm
Transmission	5-speed manual	5-speed manual
Claimed FE	35.60 km/kg	26.49 km/kg

The Tiago CNG has the more powerful engine, producing 16 PS and 13 PS more than the Celerio CNG. Both vehicles, in their respective trim levels, have a 5-speed manual gearbox. However, the Tata Tiago CNG also gets an automatic transmission in its higher trim levels.

Automatic transmission in the higher variants of Tiago CNG

(Image used for representational purposes)

Features

Features	Maruti Celerio VXi CNG	Tata Tiago XE CNG	Tata Tiago XM CNG
Exterior	Halogen headlights Body-coloured door handles and outside rear-view mirrors (ORVMs) Chrome accents on front grille 14-inch steel wheels with full wheel cover	Halogen headlights Black door handles and outside rear-view mirrors (ORVMs) 14-inch steel wheels without covers	Halogen headlights Black door handles and outside rear-view mirrors (ORVMs) LED indicator on ORVMs 14-inch steel wheels with full wheel cover
Interior	Day-night inside rear-view mirror (IRVM) Front cabin lamp 60:40 split folding rear seat Rear parcel tray Vanity mirror on co-driver sunvisor Front seat back pockets Fabric seats Integrated headrests front and rear	Day-night inside rear-view mirror (IRVM) Collapsible grab handles Fabric seats Adjustable headrests at the front	Day-night inside rear-view mirror (IRVM) Collapsible grab handles Fabric seats Adjustable headrests at the front
Infotainment	No infotainment	No infotainment	3.5-inch infotainment display 2 speakers Bluetooth connectivity
Comfort and Convenience	Analog instrument cluster with MID Manual AC All four power windows with driver-side auto up/down Electrically adjustable outside rear-view mirrors (ORVMs) Front power outlet (12V) Engine idle start/stop	Semi-digital instrument cluster Manual AC Front power outlet (12V) Manual windows Manually adjustable ORVMs	Semi-digital instrument cluster Manual AC All four power windows Electrically-adjustable ORVMs Front power outlet (12V)
Safety	Dual front airbags ABS with EBD Electronic Stability Control (ESC) Speed- and impact sensing auto door lock Front disc brakes Reverse parking sensors	Dual front airbags ABS with EBD Electronic Stability Control (ESC) ISOFIX child seat mounts Central locking Engine immobiliser Front disc brakes Rear parking sensors	Dual front airbags ABS with EBD Electronic Stability Control (ESC) ISOFIX child seat mounts Central locking Engine immobiliser Front disc brakes Reverse parking display and sensors

Of the three options here, the Tata Tiago XM CNG gets the lead on exterior design, with LED turn indicators on the ORVM, making it appear more premium from the outside. On the inside, the Celerio and Tiago offer similar levels of material, but the former includes conveniences like a split folding rear seat, rear parcel tray, and magazine pockets.

The Tiago XM CNG, on the other hand, does have an infotainment system (with a tiny display) with Bluetooth connectivity and two speakers, which are all missing from the Celerio VXi CNG.

In terms of comfort, all options offer manual air conditioning, and only the base-level Tiago CNG misses out on power windows. But the Celerio has the advantage again by including a one-touch up-down feature in the driver's window, which even the Tiago XM CNG does not get. The front headrests in the Tata Tiago CNG variants are adjustable, whereas in the Celerio, they are integrated into the seats.

The safety suite is also similar, but the Tiago provides ISOFIX child seat mounts, making it safer for families travelling with kids.

What About The Boot?

One aspect where the Tata Tiago CNG has the Maruti Celerio CNG truly beat is the practicality of the boot. The Tiago gets dual CNG tanks housed below the boot floor, allowing usable storage space, whereas the Celerio has a single tank that takes up most of the claimed 313-litre boot space offered in the petrol-powered Celerio.

Tata Tiago CNG dual-cylinder CNG tank

Verdict

Choosing between these two entry-level CNG hatchbacks can be difficult, but the Tata Tiago XM CNG does offer more for its premium. It has a more powerful powertrain and a feature set that includes more of the basic comfort features.

The Maruti Celerio VXi CNG, on the other hand, has a more refined engine that produces significantly less power. Notably, this is the only CNG variant available in the current Celerio lineup. You could use the money saved compared to the Tiago XM CNG on accessories like an infotainment system. Maruti also has a better reputation for its after-sales network.

Meanwhile, the most affordable option here, the Tiago XE CNG, has very little in its favour, as the premium for the Celerio Vxi CNG is easily justifiable for the added conveniences.

In summary, the Tata Tiago XM CNG offers better value as a whole over the Maruti Celerio VXi CNG. Which do you prefer between the Tata Tiago XM CNG and the Maruti Celerio VXi CNG? Tell us in the comments below.

Want instant updates on the automotive world? Please follow the CarDekho WhatsApp channel.